Hash trumps case

2008-05-10T11:37:00Z

# Two equivalent functions
def rgb(color)
  case color
    when :red   then 'ff0000'
    when :green then '00ff00'
    when :blue  then '0000ff'
    else             '000000' # Default to black
  end
end

def rgb2(color)
  {
    :red   => 'ff0000',
    :green => '00ff00',
    :blue  => '0000ff'
  }[color] || '000000'
end

Even though these functions are equivalent, the second carries more semantic weight – it maps a symbol directly to a color. The case sample makes no such guarantees since you can execute any arbitrary code in the then block. In addition, a hash is easier to work with – you can easily iterate over the keys, extract to another method if you need reuse, or query it for other properties (for example, 3 colors are available). It is also easier to read – both aesthetically and because it contains fewer tokens. In almost all circumstances I will prefer a hash over a case statement.

Relationships in data are easier to comprehend and manipulate than relationships in code.

Case - Xavier Shay's Blog

Hash trumps case